Leaders who walk past misconduct set the standard
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
A senior employment lawyer says that employers must treat harmful workplace behaviour as a legal, safety, and people risk, and that leadership inaction is never neutral.
Employers that treat workplace culture as separate from legal risk are misreading their obligations, according to employment law partner Fay Calderone at national law firm Hall & Wilcox, who says senior leaders are the most powerful cultural signals in any organisation.
“What they say, what they do and, critically, what they allow to pass without challenge tells everybody else where the boundaries really sit,” Calderone said in conversation with HR Leader.
Overlapping obligations
Calderone said Australian employers face overlapping duties under discrimination, Fair Work and work health and safety (WHS) laws. Under WHS law, bullying, harassment, conflict and poor workplace relationships are recognised psychosocial hazards. Persons conducting a business or undertaking (PCBUs) must eliminate psychosocial risks or, where that is not reasonably practicable, minimise them so far as is reasonably practicable.
If leaders are contributing to hostility towards a particular group, or normalising behaviour that excludes or intimidates others, Calderone said, “that is not simply a ‘culture problem’”. It calls for a risk-management response: identify what is happening, assess the risks, consult employees, intervene and test whether controls are working.
The central proposition of her latest book, Rise Up, is that leaders are “custodians of culture”, arguing that employees take their cues less from posters and policies than from what happens when someone crosses the line. “If nothing happens, that silence communicates something,” Calderone said.
Political rhetoric in the workplace
On the question of political rhetoric, online commentary and controversial public statements spilling into the workplace, Calderone said workplaces do not sit outside society. Polarisation, international conflicts and online commentary “inevitably travel through the office door”.
The employer’s role, she said, is not to manufacture ideological agreement but to create conditions in which people with different views can still work together safely and respectfully. That requires distinguishing between a genuinely different or controversial opinion and conduct that creates workplace risk or unlawfully targets another person.
Rather than asking whether the organisation agrees with someone’s politics, she said employers should ask:
- What is the connection with their employment?
- What workplace policy or law has been breached?
- What is the evidence?
- Is the conduct inconsistent with their employment duties?
- Does it have the potential to affect the reputation or viability of the organisation?
- Are we following a procedurally fair process?
Social cohesion, she said, “isn’t about creating an echo chamber”. It is about giving diverse people enough trust and safety to disagree while continuing to work respectfully together.
Gender-based harassment beyond the office
Calderone said the boundary of the workplace has changed fundamentally. Harm affecting someone at work can originate on social media, in a messaging app, at an industry event, during work travel, or outside conventional working hours. She noted that Safe Work Australia expressly recognises that gender-based harassment can occur remotely, at work-related events and virtually, including by phone, email and social media.
Under the federal Sex Discrimination Act, she said, employers and PCBUs have a positive duty to take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate, as far as possible, sex discrimination, sex-based harassment, hostile workplace environments on the ground of sex and related victimisation. The Australian Human Rights Commission has made clear the duty is proactive, so the burden is no longer simply on workers to report harm after it happens. Calderone said the laws aim to put “a fence at the top of the hill rather than an ambulance at the bottom”.
In practice, she said, employers should:
- Understand where risks actually arise in their organisation.
- Consult their people.
- Identify higher-risk environments and behaviours.
- Establish clear standards of conduct.
- Provide safe reporting pathways.
- Ensure leaders intervene when standards are breached.
They also need to consider intersectionality, because some workers face compounded risks. These steps reflect the Human Rights Commission’s guidance on satisfying the positive duty.
Calderone said employers should stop assuming conduct is irrelevant because it happens online or after hours. The commission said relevant unlawful conduct can arise in contexts not limited to the physical workplace or the working hours of those involved. “The real question is whether there is a sufficient workplace connection and whether the conduct is creating or contributing to risk for employees at work,” she said.
Because Safe Work Australia identifies gender-based harassment as a hazard capable of causing psychological and physical harm, she said employers should approach it like other hazards: identify it, assess the risk, put effective controls in place and review them.
The cost of looking away
Calderone said policies and annual training “will achieve very little” if senior people tolerate behaviour that contradicts them. Failing to detect, acknowledge or act on everyday disrespect can be perceived as implicit or explicit approval, she said, drawing on her books Rise Up and Broken to Safe. Leaders need to model respect, call out inappropriate behaviour, listen to lived experience and make it genuinely safe for people to speak up.
On what the law expects of leaders who witness inappropriate behaviour and fail to act, she said: “One of the most dangerous ideas in workplace culture is that doing nothing is somehow neutral.”
WHS laws recognise workplace interactions and behaviours as potential psychosocial hazards, and SafeWork NSW says PCBUs must manage those risks and consult workers who may be affected. Once a leader sees conduct creating a material workplace risk, Calderone said, the sensible response is not to wait and see whether someone lodges a formal complaint. The Respect at Work laws, she added, focus on prevention rather than complaints.
“The standard you walk past becomes part of the standard people believe applies,” she said. A leader who intervenes early signals that respect is real, while one who repeatedly looks away “risks signalling that compliance with policies and the law are optional”.
From reactive HR to preventative governance
Calderone said the biggest shift needed is from reactive HR to preventative governance, treating harmful behaviour as a people risk, legal risk, and safety risk at once.
She said she would put five questions to boards and executives:
- What behaviour are our leaders actually modelling?
- Where are our material psychosocial and discrimination risks, and what evidence tells us that?
- Do employees have a genuinely safe way to raise concerns?
- When senior or commercially valuable people breach standards, are consequences actually applied, or do we tolerate “brilliant jerks”?
- What are we measuring so the board knows whether the culture is improving rather than merely assuming that it is?
Calderone said she created the SAFE framework in her previous book, Broken to Safe, and the RISE framework in Rise Up to address these issues. The RISE framework sets out four leadership disciplines: resist silence and regression; invest in strategy, culture and communication; strengthen inclusion through metrics and accountability; and elicit action.
She said organisations should move beyond asking whether they have the right policy. “The better question is: ‘What experience are our people actually having and what are leaders doing about it?’”
Culture, she said, “is not what an organisation says in its values statement; it is what leaders model, permit and fail to challenge”.
RELATED TERMS
According to the Australian Human Rights Commission, discrimination occurs when one individual or group of people is regarded less favourably than another because of their origins or certain personality traits. When a regulation or policy is unfairly applied to everyone yet disadvantages some persons due to a shared personal trait, that is also discrimination.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?Make HR Leader a preferred news source on Google.