Doctor challenges state’s power to impose employment conditions
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
A medical practitioner sacked over her vaccination status has failed in her bid to have Victoria’s COVID-19 employment requirements declared constitutionally invalid.
The Federal Court has rejected a bid by Beverely Peers, formerly a visiting medical officer anaesthetist with Eastern Health, to have Victoria’s Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (PHW Act) declared constitutionally invalid due to alleged inconsistencies with provisions under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act).
Peers had her nine-year tenure at the health network cut short in December 2022 due to serious misconduct relating to her vaccination status, including a failure to follow directions.
In submissions to the court, Peers – representing herself – insisted the reason for her termination was “immaterial and irrelevant”, because she was “not seeking remedy against Eastern Health in relation to reinstatement nor am I seeking financial compensation for any perceived unfair dismissal”.
Instead, she sought declarations the PHW Act, and specifically the COVID-19 pandemic orders made under it, operated as industrial relations laws by imposing employment conditions, and was therefore invalid under the FW Act.
Peers also argued the Commonwealth had legislated comprehensively in the industrial relations field, effectively leaving no room for the Victorian laws to operate.
Justice Timothy McEvoy concluded the court did not have jurisdiction to adjudicate the dispute and, even if it were appropriate to do so, grant Peers’ declaratory relief. He added the declarations in Peers’ terms should not be made.
In coming to this decision, Justice McEvoy dismissed Peers’ claims of direct and indirect inconsistencies with the FW Act, accepting the state of Victoria’s submissions on validity instead.
Given Peers did not seek reinstatement or monetary compensation of any kind, Justice McEvoy also determined there would be no utility in making the declarations.
Peers also made unsuccessful submissions on Eastern Health’s corporate policies, namely that the unidentified policies were invalid under section 109 of the Constitution and that they allowed the state to circumvent that particular section.
Citation: Peers v Eastern Health [2026] FCA 1677.
RELATED TERMS
When a company terminates an employee's job for improper or illegitimate reasons, it is known as an unfair dismissal.
