Worker pays price for conduct linked to youth justice centre assaults
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
An ACT youth justice worker dismissed over conduct that led to assaults on young residents has failed in her unfair dismissal claim.
A former youth worker at Bimberi Youth Justice Centre, located about an hour from Canberra’s city centre, claimed her termination in April for serious misconduct was “disproportionate”.
About a year earlier, the worker failed to lock a door that separated the residents of two wings. Other than when residents are secured in their cabins, the door must be locked to prevent the risk of violence.
Although the door was unlocked and left that way while residents were secured, the worker failed to lock it before they were released.
The residents of one wing noticed the door was unlocked, entered it, and split up to physically assault two residents of the other wing.
The worker intervened and was herself assaulted in the process.
Over the next few months, the worker was notified she was the subject of an investigation and was invited to respond.
Referring to a letter in which the worker acknowledged her error and apologised, a report by the Professional Standards Unit found the serious misconduct allegations to be “proven by admission”.
In an internal record, a sanction delegate said the worker’s “lapse of judgement and due diligence resulted in these young people coming into contact with each other which resulted in serious injury”.
In submissions to the Fair Work Commission, the worker said it was an “oversimplification to say that her failure to lock the middle door resulted in the physical assault of a young person, because the error was unintentional and the assault was caused by other young people”.
The AI-generated submission “overlooks” the safety-critical role she had, commissioner Sarah McKinnon said in her decision.
While the commission acknowledged that the worker immediately accepted responsibility for the incident and expressed her regret, it noted that she went into the proceedings with the inference that responsibility for the incident should be shared with others.
“I am satisfied that the reason for [the worker’s] dismissal was sound, defensible and well-founded,” McKinnon said.
“It was a valid reason for dismissal.”
RELATED TERMS
When a company terminates an employee's job for improper or illegitimate reasons, it is known as an unfair dismissal.
