4.9% and rising: The trade-off Australia won’t admit it’s making
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Last week’s number was a warning. Blaming AI lets everyone off the hook – government most of all. The harder conversation is about what kind of country we want to be, and whether we’re willing to pay for it, writes Annalinde Nickisch.
AI is a convenient excuse
Australia’s unemployment rate hit 4.9 per cent in October, its highest level since October 2021 and the third monthly rise in a row, according to figures released on 19 November by the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Over the past year, the number of unemployed Australians grew faster than the number of jobs. Youth unemployment now sits at 11.3 per cent.
Ask who’s to blame and you’ll hear the same answer: artificial intelligence. It’s the story companies prefer to tell. Last week, Qantas announced 850 job cuts as part of an “AI-driven overhaul” with Accenture. Read past the headline, though, and some of those corporate functions are simply moving overseas. Telstra’s AI joint venture cut jobs too, with some work shifting to India. Woolworths has confirmed plans to send some corporate roles offshore. Officeworks is moving back-office and tech work to India and the Philippines.
The jobs aren’t going to a computer. They’re going to a country. And the government’s own research backs this up: jobs most exposed to AI have kept growing, just more slowly than others, according to a July report from the federal Department of Employment and Workplace Relations. AI makes a tidy headline. It isn’t the main story.
The $4 T-shirt problem
Walk into Kmart and you can buy a candle, a phone cable or a kids’ T-shirt for a few dollars. Australians love it. Kmart built its success on exactly that.
Nobody seriously thinks those things are made here. They can’t be. A worker on an Australian wage, with super, leave and insurance on top, cannot make a $4 T-shirt. Neither can a factory paying Australian rents, energy prices and compliance costs.
That’s the contradiction at the heart of this. We’ve built an economy around Australian wages and conditions, then opened the door to prices only a low-wage economy can deliver. No shopper should be expected to fix that at the checkout. A $4 T-shirt on an Australian shelf isn’t a consumer choice. It’s a policy choice.
The same logic now applies to services. An Australian business isn’t competing with the firm down the road. It’s competing with one in Manila or Bangalore that can serve the same customer for a fraction of the cost. When customers want the lowest price, the job follows the lowest cost.
Look in your medicine cabinet
If you want to see where this road ends, look at pharmaceuticals. More than 90 per cent of the medicines Australians use are imported. Australia has very little capacity to make active pharmaceutical ingredients, so even the medicines finished here usually rely on ingredients from China and India.
This didn’t happen because Australians can’t make medicine. It happened because making it here stopped making sense. Labour and compliance costs are part of it. So is the way government sets prices: the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme has driven the price of off-patent medicines so low that most of their manufacturing has moved offshore. We regulate the cost of making it here up, regulate the price we’ll pay for it down, then act shocked when the factory closes. It’s the Kmart principle, applied by government.
We found out what that costs during COVID-19, and again when hundreds of medicines went into shortage. The same trade-off plays out every week at the checkout. We just don’t notice it there.
You can’t have it both ways
Here’s the uncomfortable truth. Australia has made a choice to be a high-wage, high-protection country. That’s a legitimate choice, and plenty of Australians would make it again. But it comes with a bill, and we’ve refused to pay it.
Think of it as three things we want at once: high wages with strong worker protections, open borders to cheap imports and offshore labour, and plenty of secure local jobs. We can have any two. We cannot have all three.
Right now, we’ve picked the first two. We insist on Australian wages, then let goods made on a fraction of those wages compete freely on our shelves. Then we wonder why the third thing, the jobs, keeps leaving.
If we want to keep our standards, we have to protect them. That means tariffs or import levies on goods made without the wages and standards we require here, so local manufacturers can compete on a level field. It means government procurement that favours local production. And it means treating medicines, food and critical goods as sovereign capability, the way we already treat defence. A $4 T-shirt shouldn’t be on an Australian shelf if it only exists because of wages and standards we’d never accept for our own workers.
What we can’t keep doing is nothing.
The obvious objections
Critics will say this is just the market working: consumers get cheaper goods, and Australian workers move into better-paid jobs. For decades that was largely true. But it assumes the better jobs keep appearing, and with unemployment rising and youth unemployment above 11 per cent, that assumption is looking shaky.
Others will point to Germany, which has strong unions and heavy regulation and still makes things. But Germany also has scale, a massive export market on its doorstep and an industrial policy built around keeping manufacturing at home. We have the regulation without the strategy.
And yes, protectionism has a cost. Tariffs raise prices, and the protected industries of the 1970s were no model of efficiency. But there’s a cost to the path we’re on as well. It shows up in a youth unemployment rate above 11 per cent, in medicine shortages, and in a country that’s slowly losing the ability to make what it needs.
The choice
Last week’s number was a warning. Blaming AI lets everyone off the hook – government most of all. The harder conversation is about what kind of country we want to be, and whether we’re willing to pay for it.
We chose to be a high-wage country. Now we need the protections that go with it: a price on imports that undercut the standards we ask of our own workers and a real plan to make things here again. Without that, we should stop acting surprised when the jobs leave.
Annalinde Nickisch is the chief people officer at Probiotec Limited.
