If your CEO were accused of family violence, would your governance system cope?
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Your board decides who is entrusted with positions of power in your organisation, what authority they have, and how you will know if they are abusing that power, writes Roger Chao.
There has been growing recognition that family violence can affect work. Employees covered by the National Employment Standards have 10 days of paid family and domestic violence leave each year. WorkSafe Victoria advises that employers should assume family violence may affect their workplace. It provides employers with information about disclosures and safety plans, as well as the use of workplace facilities by perpetrators. Our Watch provides an abundance of information for workplaces that want to help stop violence against women and support employees who have experienced it.
All of this leaves us with the question of what happens if the person you believe may be using family violence is an employee.
Sam Wood was recently charged with domestic violence offences. While these remain allegations and have not been proven, they relate to an incident alleged to have occurred during a family holiday in Noosa. Several companies and commercial partners have ended or suspended their relationships with Mr Wood or his fitness company following the charges. On 6 October, DBG Health (the parent company of his fitness business) stated that it had terminated all commercial arrangements with Mr Wood, effective immediately. Mr Wood’s lawyer has said he will defend the charges.
In this situation, we are looking at a founder and commercial figure, so it is different from that of a CEO. I am not commenting on whether the alleged conduct occurred. However, when our organisation receives information like this, what should we do? We need to consider the safety of those potentially affected, including any children, while respecting the rights of the person accused.
Your company may have a family violence policy in place. It may also offer confidential support and EAP services and train managers to support an employee. Your company may also support campaigns to stop violence against women.
None of these steps necessarily provides you with the answer to what your organisation will do if it is your CEO who is believed to have used family violence.
It gets greyer when you consider what directors should do.
Private behaviour
There are many reasons a company should not get involved in its employees’ private lives.
When someone accepts employment, they do not give their employer a general right to judge their relationships, religion, activities, or other private-life choices. As a director, you should be wary of organisations that want to control behaviour merely because it makes them look bad.
However, “private” can be a tricky answer when you start talking about violence and abuse of power.
Suppose you received credible allegations that your CEO was using family violence against their partner. Nothing is alleged to have happened at work. They did not use company property and have not been found guilty of a crime. As a board, do you do nothing?
Employees can sometimes be dismissed for behaviour that happens outside work. In Rose v Telstra Corporation Limited (1998), the Australian Industrial Relations Commission examined when out-of-hours behaviour may justify dismissal because of its connection to employment. This can include conduct involving criminal offences, but a criminal charge or offence does not automatically justify dismissal. Sufficient evidence must support the connection to employment.
In Lonnie v WA Council on Addictions Incorporated (2023), the Fair Work Commission considered allegations of domestic violence involving a senior employee. It was not satisfied that allegations concerning conduct largely outside work established a valid reason for dismissal, but found that threatening messages sent using the employer’s phone did provide a valid reason. Allegations about someone’s private behaviour are different from findings of workplace misconduct. These are examples, and each CEO will have different contractual and legal considerations to keep in mind.
So, how do we apply this to our directors and CEOs?
When we hire a CEO, we give them significant power over other people. They can dismiss employees, allocate resources and access confidential information. They can also affect people’s pay and promotions. Your CEO sets the standard for who you are as a company.
If established, some behaviour outside work may show us that someone is not fit to exercise that power. We need sufficient evidence of the behaviour and a relevant connection to their role in the company.
Existing workplace guidance recognises that an employee’s leadership responsibilities can be relevant when organisations respond to family violence. Boards need to consider what I call power-relevant behaviour – behaviour outside the organisation that could affect someone’s suitability to exercise power over others within it.
Boards need to consider this as part of governance, within the limits of current dismissal laws. It should be linked to their role in your organisation and limited to specific behaviours. You don’t want to police your CEO’s private life.
Family violence and abuse can fall under this proposed definition of power-relevant behaviour.
Family violence under section 4AB of the Family Law Act 1975 includes violent, threatening or other behaviour that coerces or controls a family member or causes them to be fearful. WorkSafe Victoria also outlines that family violence can involve physical, sexual, psychological or economic abuse. It can also include threats and dominating behaviour. Family violence may involve an ongoing pattern of coercive control, including behaviours that are not necessarily reported to police or prosecuted as individual criminal offences.
Family violence can affect people of any gender, while violence against women also occurs outside family relationships. Men’s violence against women is also linked to broader patterns of gender inequality and the abuse of power. I will focus on men using family violence against women.
As a board, you should consider whether the alleged behaviour relates to the power you have given that person. This doesn’t mean you should automatically act on it or have unlimited power over someone’s private life.
It means you should consider whether “it happened at home” is enough to end the discussion.
The company needs to look at its power structure
Suppose an employee is reported to be using family violence. That report may go to their manager and possibly HR. From there, management may escalate it.
What happens when the person accused of using family violence is the CEO?
Maybe an employee becomes aware. Maybe HR finds out. A journalist approaches your company. The police get involved, and the media picks it up. A victim-survivor may reach out to an employee.
If HR reports to the CEO, who will investigate? Who will engage external lawyers if the CEO controls the general counsel’s employment? Will other executives feel able to report something if the CEO appointed them or controls their salaries? What if your chair and CEO have known each other for years?
The organisation should seek specialist family violence advice before deciding what action to take. In some situations, a workplace investigation could increase the risk of harm to the victim-survivor if the person accused becomes aware of the allegations. The organisation should consider how best to support the victim-survivor and protect their safety and that of any children affected. Ask yourself: Does my governance structure cover this? How do we address reports about people who hold greater authority than those receiving the reports?
Like our whistleblower processes, we need ways for people to report concerns without them going to the person accused. A report of someone else’s family violence may not qualify as a protected disclosure under the Corporations Act.
Just because someone has made an allegation to you doesn’t automatically give you the right to investigate that person’s private behaviour or take disciplinary action against them. You need to act within your legal authority. Assess allegations carefully; they may be inaccurate or incomplete. Don’t jump to the conclusion that the individual has committed misconduct, but don’t assume that an unproven allegation is false.
Our Watch has provided information that helps companies deal with employees who use violence against women. The Champions of Change Coalition has also developed workplace guidance with specialist organisations, including Our Watch and No to Violence. This guidance considers the situations that may arise when an organisation responds to allegations that an employee is using family violence.
Don’t assume the person is guilty
If we as a board think someone may have committed family violence, we shouldn’t jump to the assumption that they are guilty.
Just because allegations may have gone viral or the alleged behaviour conflicts with company values doesn’t mean they are guilty.
You may need to take lawful and proportionate steps to address an identified risk before the allegations have been proven. But you cannot conclude that an individual has committed misconduct or take disciplinary action without sufficient evidence and a relevant connection to their employment. Just because something isn’t proven doesn’t mean it didn’t happen or that the individual didn’t commit an offence. Equally, an unproven allegation does not establish that they did.
If someone is accused of committing family violence, they should have a fair opportunity to respond to the allegations.
Helping a victim-survivor and taking steps to protect their safety does not require a conviction or proof that an employee has committed misconduct. In some situations, you can protect the victim-survivor without taking disciplinary action against the employee. You may also want to consider the individual’s duties as CEO and whether it is appropriate for them to continue performing those duties given an identified risk. This can include temporarily altering their duties, arranging leave, or limiting their access to certain information, where permitted under their employment contract and applicable law. As always, ensure any action is reasonable, proportionate and lawful. You may also wish to seek specialist advice about referring employees to services for people who use family violence, where appropriate.
A company may have several options, but it should know them before it needs to use them.
Support victim-survivors, but don’t stop there
Much of the information available about family violence at work focuses on supporting employees who are victim-survivors.
This is important, but your organisation should also know what to do when an employee may be using family violence.
A recent YouGov study commissioned by Humans of Purpose Academy showed that 71 per cent of employers surveyed believed they could identify and respond to an employee experiencing domestic and family violence. Among people surveyed who had experienced domestic and family violence, only 8.3 per cent said their workplace had taken an active role in supporting them. The study also found that 89 per cent of survivors either had concerns about telling their workplace or did not disclose their experience. Only 34 per cent knew about the entitlement to paid family and domestic violence leave.
These figures measure different things across two groups of respondents, but they leave us questioning what employers believe they are doing compared with what victim-survivors actually experience.
Why do we have this gap?
WorkSafe Victoria states that family violence can enter your workplace through the perpetrator. They may contact a victim-survivor through company emails or phones, or show up at their workplace. They may use company resources to harm a family member. WorkSafe also states that family violence can affect a victim-survivor’s ability to work safely, while perpetrating family violence can also affect an employee’s ability to work safely.
You may know what to do if an employee comes to you and says their partner is hurting them. But what do you do if an employee is accused of hurting someone?
Your company values may come into play
It’s easy for your company to support someone who’s hurt by someone you don’t employ.
What if the person accused is a big earner for your company? What if that person is your CEO? Maybe they know a lot about your business that no one else knows or are in the middle of selling your business.
The commercial consequences may be significant, but they should not determine whether the organisation takes identified safety risks seriously or holds people accountable for established misconduct.
As mentioned earlier, companies have values that they want to stand for. There is a fine line between values and employment contracts. Your company should be careful when relying on its values to dismiss someone.
However, if your company’s values include opposition to violence against women, you should know what you are willing to do if an employee is believed to be using that violence.
Maybe your company stands for helping victim-survivors but has no process for dealing with employees accused of using family violence. If so, recognise that gap and decide how to address it.
Remember that terminating someone’s employment can have consequences for the victim-survivor. They may rely on that person’s income or fear for their safety if the person is terminated.
Our Watch has guidance that you should consider before terminating an employee for using violence against women. It recommends considering the victim-survivor’s safety, seeking specialist and legal advice, and, where it is safe and lawful, consulting victim-survivors who are also employees.
What should you know before it happens?
You should know where to report it and who will investigate.
What will your company do with that information? How will you keep it confidential?
How will you treat allegations that someone has been using family violence? The alleged conduct could have happened at work or away from work. Consider whether the conduct is relevant to employment. Did they use company resources? Was another employee involved? Does it create a safety hazard in the workplace? Could it affect their ability to do their job? Is there enough evidence that they engaged in this behaviour to question whether they should continue to hold that position of power in your organisation?
These may be relevant considerations, depending on the circumstances and applicable law.
Don’t forget that you oversee the process and don’t necessarily need to get involved in an individual case. You may need to protect the victim-survivor’s identity. Remember that if your employee takes family and domestic violence leave, rules govern how you handle the information they provide, including confidentiality requirements. You may also need to comply with privacy laws.
Victim-survivors may experience additional forms of discrimination that make it harder for them to access the help and safety they need. Your organisation’s processes should take account of these barriers.
Depending on what you decide to do with your CEO, it may also affect their position as a director. If your CEO is also a director of a public company, removing them as a director would generally require shareholder action, separate from any decision about their CEO role.
You should have access to legal advice and family violence experts if someone in a senior position is accused of using family violence, including advice on protecting the victim-survivor and any children affected. The victim-survivor’s views and understanding of their own safety should inform your organisation’s response where it is safe and appropriate to obtain them. Respect their privacy, seek specialist advice where necessary, and don’t make them responsible for your organisation’s decision.
There may be cases where you are unable to obtain enough evidence to substantiate an allegation or justify disciplinary action. This does not mean you should ignore identified safety concerns or withhold appropriate support from the victim-survivor. You may also determine that there is sufficient evidence to justify disciplinary action. Your organisation must know how to distinguish between these situations.
Know your power
Your board decides who is entrusted with positions of power in your organisation, what authority they have, and how you will know if they are abusing that power.
Family violence can be hard to address because it often happens in someone’s private life.
The AICD has recently supported proposed legislative changes to address financial abuse through coerced directorships. These involve situations where someone is pressured or coerced into becoming a company director, allowing corporate structures and obligations to be misused for financial abuse.
Our Watch states that the commitments and actions of senior executives and board members are critical to changing the attitudes, behaviours and structures that contribute to violence against women. What will you do if that behaviour comes from one of your own people?
Know who you will speak to and how you will address it.
Roger Chao is a board adviser and governance consultant, board chair, non-executive director, and audit and risk committee chair.
